Best Mascara for Older Women [Updated for 2021]

Nobody likes raccoon eyes, and unfortunately, the problem only grows as your age matures. That’s why you’re probably here looking for the best mascara for older women and we’re glad to say that we got the perfect list for you!

Best Mascara for Older Women

 As a poised woman of a certain age, you shouldn’t let cheap mascara dull the sparkle in your eyes. 

You don’t have to be a queen to show your regality. With my help, your eye makeup will speak volumes about your natural grace and beauty. From the best drugstore mascara for mature eyes to the high-end luxury brands, I’ve got you and your lashes covered.


PhotoProductEditor's RatingPrice
Best mascara for older womenbareMinerals Escentuals Lashtopia Mineral-Based Mascara4.5VIEW CURRENT PRICE
Best mascara for older womenHonest Beauty Extreme Length and Lash Primer5VIEW CURRENT PRICE
71pO5x4IkrL._SX466_Estée Lauder Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara4VIEW CURRENT PRICE
mascara__21160.1519966459.500.750Ecco Bella Brown Mascara4.5VIEW CURRENT PRICE

bareMinerals Escentuals Lashtopia Mega Volume Mineral-Based Mascara

Best mascara for older women

Wow, try saying that name five times fast! Forgetting about that mouthful of a name and focusing on the brilliant all-day formula that this brand flawlessly delivers. bareMinerals has dubbed itself the “creator of clean beauty.” So, all of their products are cruelty-free, paraben-free, formaldehyde-free, and mineral oil-free. Talk about guilt-free shopping!

bareMineral created their Lashtopia Mega Volume Mascara with the intention of nourishing and conditioning your lashes while also lifting and fanning them out.

I love how smooth this mascara is. I’ve never experienced clumping or flakes when using it. When it comes to finding the best mascara for thinning lashes, this is the brand I always recommend. bareMinerals is perfect for those with sensitive eyes and skin, and the conditioning formula helps your lashes stay soft and flexible.

  • Hydrating conditioning formula
  • Thick brush for application
  • Perfect Consistency
  • Not waterproof

  • Brush is too thick


Where to Buy: Sephora, bareMinerals, Walmart, Ulta.


Honest Beauty Extreme Length and Lash Primer

Best mascara for older women

If you’re looking for a natural way to make your lashes longer and stronger, this is your miracle solution. Honest’s 2-in-1 dual-ended primer and mascara is ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested and approved. Adding the facts of this mascara being cruelty-free, paraben-free, silicone-free, and mineral-oil free, it seems like this mascara knocks it out of the park with clean beauty.

To apply, you start with the lash primer. It helps your lashes grow and creates a great base for your mascara to lay on, so it stays on! Then, you finish with the dark side to create a rich, smooth coat of lifting mascara. You get definition, volume, and longer lashes all at once. What’s not to love?

Customers are absolutely raving about this mascara. One reviewer, in particular, claimed that her thin, straight lashes grew twice in length after putting the primer on. I honestly have nothing to complain about with Honest Beauty’s mascara. It doesn’t smudge or flake, even during your sweatiest workout or on the rainiest day. 

  • Instant lash volume
  • Exclusive vitamin blend
  • Fragance Free
  • Safe for contact wearers
  • I wish the tube was bigger!


Where to Buy:, Walmart, Ulta,


Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara

Sumptuous Extreme by Estée Lauder seems to magically multiple, magnify, and grow your lashes in one swish of your mascara wand. For the best volume mascara for older women, there’s no one that does it better. Estée Lauder Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara uses a blend of three high-volume fibers in a mousse formula base. It’s like wearing lash extensions while actually growing your natural lashes.


The packaging features an over-sized brushcomber that thickens your lashes while also fanning them out. The mascara itself is fortified with a mixture of vitamins that condition your lashes to encourage growth. However, no product is perfect.


I do have a few qualms about Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Mascara. I found the formula a little too runny. It doesn’t dry fast enough, so you end up getting some of it on your lids and need to use a q-tip to clean it up. Also, customers with sensitive eyes have said that they had a reaction to this particular formula.

  • Instant lash volume
  • Exclusive vitamin blend
  • Fragance Free
  • Safe for contact wearers
  • Formula can be too runny

  • May not be suitable for sensitive eyes


Where to Buy: Walmart, Estée Lauder, Macy’s, Sephora.


Ecco Bella Brown Mascara

What is the best mascara for over 60s that will change your makeup routine forever? The secret lies with Ecco Bella FlowerColor Brown Mascara. For luxurious natural lashes, this vegan formula uses clay and flower cutins to create length and volume for fuller lashes.

The FlowerColor formula is water-resistant and lasts all day. The best part is that you don’t need to scrub your eyes to wash it off. It’s made for sensitive eyes, so the delicate skin around your eyes is gently protected.

  • Superior brush design
  • Ethically made products
  • Fuller lashes without clumps
  • Comes in five colors.
  • Self-sharpening for clean-cut lines.
  • Easy to wash off with mineral water and basic cleansers.
  • Bad packaging

  • It dries out fast on some units
  • Expensive


Where to Buy: Amazon, Ecco Bella, Ebay.


The Best Mascara for Older Women: Buying and Styling Guide

Should Mature Women Curl their Lashes Before Applying Mascara?

This is a common question, especially if you have straight lashes that just won’t lift. While I love a good lash curler as much as the next girl, if you have deep-set or hooded eyes, curling your lashes can result in the mascara rubbing onto your upper lid and brow line. Even when your mascara is dry, you could end up with a smudge line after a long day. 


Should you Wear Eyeliner, Even With Mature Eyes?

Again, I’m the kind of girl who loves a full, fierce makeup look. Wearing eyeliner without mascara is a cosmetic sin to me, and vice versa. If you don’t feel like your look is bold enough with just mascara, then go on and add some eyeliner. Now, the real question is how can you put on eyeliner when your skin isn’t as smooth as it used to be?

Definitely don’t pull your skin to straighten out your lid. Instead, lift your brow with one hand, while applying your eyeliner with the other. Whether you go with a pencil or liquid, make sure that you’re using a lightweight liner on your eyes and only use a small amount.


Create a Cleansing Routine that Removes Every Pigment at the End of the Day.

Just as important as how you apply mascara, is how you take it off. As you develop more wrinkles, the harder it becomes to take off your eye makeup. It’s annoying but true. Make sure that you are using cleansers that are gentle on your skin, but will still remove sticky, stubborn makeup. After cleansing your skin, use makeup wipes to clear away any residue left over. Finish with eye cream, serums, and moisturizer, and you have already prepped your face for tomorrow’s look!


Best Mascara for Older Women: The Final Word

When it comes to choosing the right mascara, there’s no way to tell which product will work best for your unique eyes. We each have unique eye colors, shapes, and sizes. And then factoring in your ideal brands, wand types, and personal preferences, it really comes down to what you like.

The best advice I can give is for you to use trial and error to find the mascara that works for you. Keep trying different products until you find the one that makes you feel like the confident goddess you are. And then work those lashes all day long!

Leave a Reply